My name is Bryan Penfound. Awhile back I was asked if I would be interested in helping out at MathMistakes and I said yes not knowing how challenging this term would be for me. Now that I have settled in a little bit, I thought I was a bit overdue for a post, so here goes!
Recently while volunteering at a local high school in a grade 9 classroom, I had to opportunity to observe students’ answers to the following question: “Create a trinomial in the variable t that has degree 3 and a constant term of -4.”
Here are five of my favourite responses:
I would love to get some discussion going. Choose one of the polynomials above and try to deconstruct what the student knows and what the student still has misconceptions about. What follow-up questions might you ask to learn more information about how the student is thinking? What follow-up questions might you ask to help with any current misconceptions?
How would you help this student?
Another thought: would this student have made this mistake at the beginning of the problem? In other words, is this mistake more likely to happen as the problem goes on than at the beginning? If so, then what does that say about problem-solving?
Thanks to Anna for the submission!
What’s the fastest way of helping these students?
Thanks to Anna for the submissions.
There’s a lot going on here. What about this work do you find the most interesting? How would you help this student?
Thanks to Heather for the submission!
I think the temptation I have is to call this a “careless” mistake and urge more practice. Let’s probe deeper.
1. What does this kid know and understand about exponents?
2. What’s the fastest way to help?
3. What makes this mistake so tempting?
Thanks to Sadie Estrella for the awesome addition to our ever-mounting pile of exponents mistakes.
Kelli Prine submits the above, and asks “This student keeps factoring the terms and canceling. What can I do to clarify the process?”
I expect some excellent comments on this one. Don’t disappoint.
How would you help this kid out?
Thanks to Chris Shore for the submission!
What’s the mistake? Diagnose the disease, and find the cure in the comments.
Thanks to Anna Blintsein for the submissions. Go follow her on twitter!
Here are two classic mistakes:
Whenever I see a mistake that recurs at all different levels, and with all different students, I wonder: what makes this mistake so attractive? What’s the misconception? And what can we do about it?
Say something smart in the comments, and then go check out this post from Fawn Nguyen.