Conditional Probability and the Rules of Probability High School: Statistics and Probability Probability

Coin Flipping

I saw this one in class last week:

Probability of flipping 10 heads when flipping 10 coins: (1/2)^10

Probability of flipping 9 heads when flipping 10 coins: (1/2)^9

2 replies on “Coin Flipping”

Well, yes, I can see that. Even if your mind is telling you, ‘the tail must figure in somewhere’, that would just lead back to (1/2)^10, which can’t be right either, as the probability should be different. Might be more interesting to see where a die roll question would go… would (5/6) factor in then, as the fail case is different?

IMO, visualizing tree diagrams or constructing sets becomes rather tricky beyond about 3 cases, so unless you’re aware (consciously or otherwise) of the binomial distribution, even an adult can miss the “order matters” issue as soon as you don’t have a simple event.

An answer I would expect to see from a more sophisticated, but more confused, student would be 10 * (1/2)^9 where the 10 represents the number of places that the 1 tail could reside. I think the mistake above can be resolved by asking the (relatively obvious to us) questions
1 – What is the probability of ten heads in a row? Good, you got that right.
2 – If I have tossed a coin 9 times and I saw heads each time, what is the probability of getting a head on the next toss?
If the student answers question 2 correctly, then proceed to build up the correct answer to the question posed in the post. If not, go back and talk about conditional probability at the appropriate level.

Comments are closed.